Monday, January 18, 2016

INDIA - GLOBAL POWER Strategic Outline

Summary

India desperately needs a comprehensive strategy regarding its role and capabilities especially military reach in current dynamic multi-polar environment. Today, the world exists with one remaining major reclusive power (USA), challenging emerging power (China), post-war victor powers with diminutive  influence (Russia, UK, France), post-war defunct powers with major economic clout (Japan, Germany) and ex-colonial devoid powers with geographical & cultural reach (Spain, Turkey, Portugal).

India's turbulent neighborhood is home to two unfriendly nuclear powers; China and Pakistan. Sadly, they continue to expand and modernize their arms capacity. Motivated by the need to address perceived security threats, each is seeking to expand ballistic missile and cruise missile-based nuclear delivery systems. The region has the 'most at risk of a breakdown in strategic stability due to an explosive mixture of unresolved territorial disputes, cross-border terrorism, and growing nuclear arsenals'.

New Delhi, like Beijing, pledges a NFU (No First Use) policy, as articulated in India's 2003 nuclear doctrine. The doctrine emphasizes that its nuclear program is intended to establish a robust but credible minimum deterrent. Moreover, the doctrine explicitly states that India's response to an external nuclear attack on its territory or armed forces anywhere would be 'massive and designed to inflict unacceptable damage'. India views Chinese nuclear expansion as a security threat, experts say, and as a result New Delhi seeks capabilities to counter Beijing, including the arena of space exploration. India's reading of Chinese nuclear activity is further colored by China's role in providing Pakistan with nuclear material and technology.

The need of the hour is to think 'big' and based on India’s geostrategic centrality, India should declare an Indian Monroe Doctrine sphere encompassing the Indian Ocean Region and, landwards, the arc of the Gulf-Caspian Sea-Central Asia and beyond. Enlargement of India's role globally requires basic encapsulation of strategic and psyche processes. At the onset, Defense Technological and Industrial Base (DTIB) has to be integrated consisting of civil / military Research & Development and production activities (or civil-military integration) enabling development of advanced military capabilities. In particular, one of India’s highest priorities for strategic modernization has to be the development of information-based C4ISR systems (command, control, communications, computers, intelligence, surveillance, and reconnaissance). It would make up an 'operational architecture' to establish worldwide connectivity with all levels of command providing situational awareness, support for intelligence, force planning, readiness assessment, and deployment applications that battlefield commanders require to effectively plan and execute joint military operations.
India has to enhance its strategic institutions (Think Tanks, Intelligence set-up, disaster / crisis mitigation) and upgrade / modify its security infrastructure for catering needs in any part of the world. This strategy outlines salient aspects of such an eventuality for India's global role and responsibility.
           
1.         Introduction
2.         India - Global power projections
3.         Trade & Commerce
4.         Cultural & Soft power, Intelligence
5.         Energy & Natural Resources / Security
6.         Conflicts /Resolution
7.         Geographical Reach
7.1                   Neighborhood
7.2                   Indo-Pacific Region
7.3                   Middle-east & Central Asia
7.4                   Africa
7.5                   Central & South America
7.6                   Arctic Region, Western Europe & North America
8.         Strategic Institutions -Think Tanks, NDRF, R & D
9.         Threat Perception
10.       Intelligence Gathering
11.       Cyber-risk, Weapons of Mass Destruction (WMD), Asymmetric Threat
12        Command, Control, Communication 
13.       Operational Reach
14.       Conclusion
            References & Images




1.         Introduction

India remains World’s second largest and, perhaps, with most diverse population consisting of largest Hindu, Buddhist and Sikh populations. It has third largest Muslim population. India’s role as a geopolitical actor can be contributed to its geography. From the Gulf and to the Straits of Malacca, India is the world’s seventh largest country with a 15,000 km border, a 7,500 km coastline and a 2 million sq km Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ). Historically, its geopolitics has been influenced by 5000 years of history and its colonial experience. Physically, India's borders are land-based, sea-based and mountainous. More importantly, these borders are long and porous; they have also not been completely delineated and demarcated. Even today they remain illogical and ill-defined. Looking back, India had attracted a variety of foreign invaders since 326 BC but it has not expanded its power abroad militarily. India has quest for autonomy in decision-making. Hence, India seeks primacy and veto over action of outside powers. India's extended neighborhood circle begins from the Persian Gulf stretches to the Straits of Malacca and the Indian Ocean, including Central Asia. Strategically, Russia, China and USA happen to be part of this circle. India seeks to balance the role of other powers. India wants to become one of the ‘poles’ in a multi-polar world and a key player in international peace and security. Having consolidated its regional position, India increasingly aspires to move into the global stage both institutionally and geographically. India is also signatory to the Antarctic Treaty (maintains a permanent station) and an observer on the Arctic Council. Globally, India has remained a responsible power adhering to the existing and emerging international norms and institutions. However, on certain issues, India has been challenging the existing order to seek greater accommodation for it in existing global institutions. Along with strategic and economical partners, India has been contributing to emerging norms and building nascent regimes – particularly in six areas: climate, cyber, energy, food, maritime and space security.

Since independence, one can trace a pattern until the 1990s, in which India responded to the regional and international geopolitical situation, based on its own security perceptions. To a large extent, India’s nuclear tests in 1974 & 1998 acted as a catalyst in reorganizing its security perceptions and, in the process, its strategic vision as well. Historically, India’s freedom struggle and initial social, economic and political challenges in the first two decades made nonalignment its strategic vision. Externally, the Cold War and India-China War of 1962 played an important role in defining the vision as well. Next powerful Prime Minister Ms. Indira Gandhi, whose strategic vision was based more on the regional and international system of the 1960s-1980s. Nuclear weapons were seen as a symbol of power and providing a security guarantee. It was only in 1999 that the National Security Council (NSC) was formed (in India). Hence, before NSC, no defense policy or strategic vision was formally enunciated in any document. Finally, Government of India was forced to promote an independent strategic culture that provides critical inputs to the government.

Today, India’s strategic vision is no more limited to the South Asian region, but it considers Central Asia, West Asia, Southeast Asia, China and farthest parts of Globe (such as South America, Central America and Alaska) as a part of its extended neighborhood. The logic of extending this regional vision is based on economic, energy security needs, liaison with Indian Diaspora world-wide, international terrorism, and proliferation of weapons of mass destruction, Cyber-attacks, trafficking of arms and narcotics, money laundering and environmental threats. India’s global strategic vision is based on shaping a new international order that includes the United States, the European Union, China, Russia, and Japan.

2.         India - Global power projections

Globally, India wanted a 'Big Power' role, but the question that remains - Is India ready yet to play that role, institutionally and structurally, whether it has a political consensus for that strategic leap and whether its forces can be deployed beyond the borders if required to match the expectations of such a role. Some in India may yet be skeptical that things may not have been too well thought out and the delivery may not be able match such vaunting ambitions.

The first big weakness of the Indian system remains its reliance on the bureaucracy, which had been good in carrying out assigned tasks, but remains incapable of leading a transformation. Besides, there exists the question of national stamina. The big shift that current government wants to bring about is to change the idea of India as 'a balancing power' into what it calls 'a leading power'. Current leadership believes that it is time a nation that houses one-sixth of humanity and is soon to be the world's third-largest economy, takes its rightful place under the sun. India reckons that with the US on a gradual decline and the Chinese shaky, India as the world's largest democracy has the opportunity to lead the world if it plays its cards well. WWII relic & defunct United Nations Security Council (UNSC) needs change. Indian Prime Minister does not shy away from being hawkish and pursuing India's national interest aggressively. His foreign policy initiatives have direct linkages to domestic economical goals. He remains acutely aware that the ambitious programmes, such as Digital India, Smart Cities, Make in India, Skill India and Start-up India, require massive infusion of capital, know-how and managerial skills to bring them to fruition rapidly. That would be possible only if foreign investors came in droves to pump money and bring in expertise. As major powers eyed India's huge market potential and its relative political stability, foreign investors have flocked to fuel the growth. FDI grew ten-fold during this period from $3 billion to $35 billion. The sustained economic growth (as China demonstrated) could single-handedly propel India to the status of a great power. Understandingly, he has pledged to treble the size of the Indian economy to $20 trillion.
In pursuit of global ambition and sustained economic growth, India has increased its naval strength in recent years and aims at transforming itself into a ‘blue-water navy’ within the next 10 to 15 years. By 2022, the Indian Navy will have 50 warships including three aircraft carriers, five nuclear submarines, 22 conventional submarines and a number of long range maritime patrol aircraft. Already, India has acquired a nuclear submarine (Akula-II) from Russia in April, 2012. Also, a second nuclear submarine of the same class will be inducted soon. Moreover, the sea trials of its indigenous nuclear submarines have been in progress.

3.         Trade & Commerce

Foreign trade negotiations, particularly in pending and upcoming FTAs (Free Trade Agreements) and RTAs (Regional Trade Agreements), would be an important determinant of India’s ability to translate words into action. The Foreign Trade Policy (2015-2020) notes the growth of mega trade agreements like the TPP (Trans-Pacific Partnership), TTIP (Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership) and RCEP (Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership) as significant developments and the need for India to understand the emerging challenges. However, it stops short of spelling out specific negotiating strategies, even for the RCEP, which India is negotiating, except for mentioning that it will work on quick conclusion of the RCEP while taking note of interests of domestic business and industry. Similarly, on trade and investment negotiations with the EU (European Union), the FTP (Foreign Trade Policy), while pointing out that India’s offers to the EU have been its most liberal among all trading partners, does not give any clear indication of how it plans to resolve the outstanding issues. It seems that the danger of trade policy remains inadequate for realizing the economic power of India. Comparatively, China’s investment and construction overseas is already worth $1.2 trillion. 

4.         Cultural & Soft power, Intelligence

Today, India's presence has become quintessentially prominent; be it the 25 million strong Indian Diaspora, Indian cuisine, Indian crafts, Indian writing in English or Indian cinema. Indian government in the last 8 years, with the help of Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) and Indian Council of Cultural Relations (ICCR), has focused more on projection of India’s soft power diplomacy.

Indian Foreign Affairs has been undergoing a slow and quiet restructuring. A long-time adherent to tradition, the foreign office is waking up to live and work very differently in the current government. For the first time, the Indian government has presented a strategic evaluation of the world to its diplomats and ambassadors. It is the first authoritative detailed assessment approved at the highest level of the political leadership, covering every region and international issues. With Prime Minister directly taking a deep interest in foreign policy, MEA is learning how to do things differently.

Along with hard power encompassing military and economic means, India's soft power relating to culture and values, has mushroomed into prominence. As well-known, soft power strategies are most effective when they are subtle and indirect. The Indian Council for Cultural Relations, the foreign office's independent arm tasked with cultural diplomacy, plans to host 26 seminars on the country's Buddhist or other historical past across multiple countries by next March with scholars, monks and policy-makers as its target audience. India’s self-discovery of its rich cultural heritage and its global reach played an important role in shaping its modern nationalism.

It is well-known fact that developing countries rely heavily on remittances and foreign direct investment as sources of funding. In case of India, reaching out to its diaspora in times of need has had significant benefits. As of 2014, a reported $71 billion inflow of remittances entered India. Tapping the patriotic nature of expatriates allowed developing countries to efficiently raise capital for necessary projects such as infrastructure or crisis relief to name a few.

India with its embassies and intelligence network world wide needs to upgrade its skills remarkably to collect necessary information required for India to become a major global power. Various kinds of intelligence—military, political, economic, social, environmental, health, and cultural—provide important information for policy decisions. Many people view intelligence gathering through secret or covert means only. However, various means can be used to collect Intelligence. A human source remains the prime collection of information.  Another probable source can be the signals referring to electronic transmissions that can be collected by ships, planes, ground sites, or satellites. Also, data captured as Imagery Intelligence (referred to as photo intelligence) becomes essential source of intelligence. Nowadays, 'Measurement and Signatures Intelligence' relatively little-known collection discipline that concerns weapons capabilities and industrial activities can be used, to help identify chemical weapons or pinpoint the specific features of unknown weapons systems. Lastly, information disseminated from Open-Source Intelligence can be used which refers to a broad array of information and sources that are generally available, including information obtained from the media (newspapers, radio, television), professional and academic records (papers, conferences, professional associations), and public data (government reports, demographics, hearings, speeches).

5.         Energy & Natural Resources / Security

In case of India, foreign policy and strategic posturing has been a matter more of compulsion than choice. One of the biggest compulsions that India faces is its burgeoning oil deficit. Currently, India imports 70 per cent of its oil needs, which is likely to grow further. India’s known oil reserves constitute 0.4 per cent of world reserves, but its consumption is 2.8 per cent of global consumption. In 1980, India consumed 36.9 million tonnes of oil, which has nearly trebled to 118 million tonnes in 2003-2004; of this only 33.4 million tonnes was domestically produced. In the year 2003, India spent US $ 20.6 billion towards import of oil. The acquisition of interests by the Oil and Natural Gas Commission (ONGC) in foreign countries like Sudan, Libya, Syria, Russia (Sakhalin-I), Kazakhstan and Vietnam helped partly mitigate the situation. At any given time, India has a domestic crude oil stockpile to cover twelve days requirement, while another eleven days stocks are in transit. India, therefore, has to ensure uninterrupted smooth supplies of oil from external sources through practice of astute diplomacy and a constant calibration of foreign policy even at the cost of other pressing imperatives.

In this context, recent political overturn in Venezuela has great significance for India, which imports 11.4% (21.59 million tonnes) of its crude oil from the Andean nation, only after Saudi Arabia and Iraq. Venezuela remains a major global oil player, with the world’s largest proven reserves of oil – 299 billion barrels. Oil accounted for 95% of the country’s exports in 2014. Recently, India-Venezuela relations have moved a notch beyond quotidian oil transactions.

Similarly, Africa too has energy security issues. Oil production in Africa began in Egypt in 1910 and only in earnest in Libya and Algeria (under French and Italian auspices) in the 1930s and 1940s. Now, there are twelve major oil producers in Africa. It is dominated in rank order of output, by Nigeria, Algeria, Libya, and Angola which collectively account for 85 percent of African output. Gabon and Equatorial Guinea are the only African oil producers with high oil per capita, comparable to the oil rich and sparsely populated states such as Kuwait and Qatar. Only Nigeria ranks within the world’s top fifteen oil producers. Nigeria, Algeria, and Libya are respectively the world’s eighth, tenth, and twelfth largest oil exporters. These three states and Gabon are members of Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC).

6.         Conflicts / Resolution

World War I brought the collapse of the Ottoman and Austrian empires and the creation of more than a dozen new countries, including nearly all those in the modern Middle East. During the two decades after World War II, control over more than half the world's surface shifted radically, as dozens of “no state actors” — then known as liberation movements — seized power and set up new regimes. The continued expansion of international trade, finance, travel, and communications has increased vulnerabilities even as it has widened horizons, increased opportunity, and lifted people around the world out of poverty. Nowadays, terrorists and criminals ostensibly mix with the millions of tourists and business people who cross national boarders every day, resulting in security agencies need to have new and more powerful tools to track and impede their movements.

Additionally, adversaries, operating through activist environmental organizations—their knowing or unknowing proxies—would manipulate influential international forums, conferences, or governing bodies in a multipronged strategy to neutralize India's military superiorities, whether technological, tactical, or strategic. These organizations’ activities would include fund-raising, press conferences, press releases, blogs, websites, social media campaigns, lobbying, meetings, conferences, and symposia, as well as partnerships with other respected NGOs and influential organizations, universities, and individuals and sponsorship of “research".

The Indian Government has joined other peace-minded nations in doing everything possible to reduce world tensions, to assist in the settlement of international disputes by peaceful means and to achieve disarmament with such controls as are necessary to preserve the security of all nations. In case of crisis or conflicts, for operational pragmatic approach, all planning, targeting, and wartime deployment of strategic forces would be under a single command, while the day-to-day operations remained with the respective services.

7.         Geographical Reach

The Strategic Command portion of India would be located in Central India (undisclosed) working as the command center for the defense "triad": the strategic bombers and ICBMs (intercontinental ballistic missiles) of the Air Force, and the Indian Navy's submarine-launched ballistic missiles. This would be the command and control center for India's strategic forces and controls military space operations, computer network operations, information operations, strategic warning and intelligence assessments as well as global strategic planning. Recently, 'Ensuring Secure Seas: Indian Maritime Security Strategy IMSS (2015)' was released by the defense minister of India at the Naval Commanders Conference on 26 October 2015. In assessing India’s maritime compulsions, the IMSS focuses attention on the security of the Indian Ocean sea lines of communication (SLOCs), the preservation of national influence in the maritime neighborhood, and the protection of overseas investment and Indians residing abroad. Consequently, it seems to prioritize security against irregular challenges in the Indian Ocean over other traditional threats. IMSS modifies approach on deterrence, coastal security and the regional strategic environment. Alongside articulating India’s peacetime maritime objective, it establishes common ground between the operational priorities of the navy and the strategic proclivities of the policy establishment – particularly the defense bureaucracy. In a world of growing geopolitical entanglements, the Indian Navy requires a forward-leaning strategic blueprint for enhanced maritime reach and deployment in the Asian & World littorals.

Revisiting the old approach of hyphenating relations, new energized India has been exploring options simultaneously to expand its scope and reach. So while it pursues an independent relationship with Iran, whatever be the US pressure, it boldly engages with Israel. While it maintains its traditional ties with Russia, it sees no contradiction in buying arms from the US. It strives to improve ties with Japan and China, while it brings a new sense of urgency in its relations with ASEAN by changing the lexicon from "Look East" to "Link West". As tacitly put by India foreign secretary, "India's current position makes it possible to simultaneously pursue multiple relationships that create a virtuous cycle where each can drive the others higher."

7.1                   Neighborhood

Managing India's troubled neighborhood would remain as challenging as the economy. Indian Prime Minister (PM) understood its importance early and declared that his foreign policy would adopt a "Neighbors First" approach. This policy places a premium on the three Cs-connectivity, cooperation and contact with South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC) members. The idea of linking the countries through roads, trade, energy and people-to-people contact looks plausible.

PM's record remains mixed on Pakistan and China, major neighborhood woes. Of late, PM in consultation with National Security Adviser has worked to isolate Pakistan on terror by building a ring of support in countries doing business with it. However, recent move by PM to have halt at Lahore to greet Pakistan Prime Minister on his birthday was an 'out-of-box' initiative. Only future would decide which way neighbors wants to proceed.

India has followed a more nuanced policy with China that triangulates economic cooperation and security concerns with international politics. Understandingly, China has emerged as the new superpower that is challenging American supremacy, India has deftly reached out to Japan and Australia along with deepening relations with the US, signaling that India was not averse to teaming up with others to contain China. In contrast, India has been founder member (with China) in BRICS and AIIB too. India hopes to leverage India's vast consumer market that China has an eye on to reach a swift and amicable solution to the border dispute and also get Beijing to rein in Pakistan.

7.2                   Indo-Pacific Region

Presently, containment of China by US remains not a plausible option. Hence, multi-polar world reality has been acknowledged by USA too. China continues to seek (through industrial espionage and military-commercial partnerships) advanced weapons and dual-use technologies from the West to support its modernization.

India-US has signed a significant Joint Strategic Vision for the Indo-Pacific and the Indian Ocean Region. It would involve India in both maritime security of the region and in expanding its trade links to Asia-Pacific, including major treaties under negotiation.
Strategically, at present, India has initiated early stages of developing its ability to project and sustain its naval presence beyond the Indian Ocean. Its continued increases in the naval budget and improvements to India’s defense infrastructure will be necessary to achieve this. As a geographic outsider to the Asia-Pacific, India needs to rely on its partners, particularly in Southeast Asia, to project power east of Malacca, further reinforcing the need for it to prove itself a credible partner in the first place. Here, France too with its territories in New Caledonia, Wallis and Futuna, French Polynesia, and Clipperton Island can become a partner in making it a regional Pacific power. Deeper engagement with the region will align with India's intentions to revitalize Indian economic growth and carve out a more prominent global role for India. In addition, prioritizing relations with India’s East and Southeast Asian partners will fulfill India’s broader strategic objectives of balancing against China’s increasing presence in the Indo-Pacific Ocean. Recently, India has taken forward policy of maintaining its dominance in the region by various naval co-operations, ties of building Deep Defense Assets in littoral countries; however it depends on accurately playing its multi vectored diplomacy and strengthening its defense infrastructure.

However, India will be unlikely to engage in any security initiatives that could be perceived as threatening or containing China. In the near term, it would not be realistic to expect India to take an active position on East Asia’s maritime territorial disputes, beyond its declared support for principles such as freedom of navigation.

India needs to have specific Indo-Pacific Command which would oversees an area of responsibility stretching from the waters of Indian Ocean & Pacific Ocean encompassing diverse Asian & Australian /New-Zealand nations. Indo-Pacific command and its partners (USA, Japan, ASEAN and Australia) would work to promote the development of the region while cooperating to enhance security, deter aggression, and respond with force when necessary and to provide humanitarian assistance.

7.3                   Middle-East & Central Asia

In reality, the Middle East, North Africa, Central Asia and much of the Islamic world remains caught up in an interlocking pattern of crises that has become steadily more serious over time, and that now seems almost certain for over at least the next decade. Apart from Western powers (USA, France, UK & Germany), the major arms race from Russia and China is accelerating military build-up and power struggle in the Gulf, Levant, Iraq, and Syria.

As 68 per cent of India’s imported oil and $US30 billion of remittances come from millions of Indian workers in the Persian Gulf, the Middle East will continue to be of significance to India. The power vacuum and resultant instability that may follow the US withdrawal from Afghanistan also has the potential to shift much Indian attention from east to west. Even so, and despite ties with Israel, India's advocacy of a “Look East, Link West” policy suggests that its broader foreign policy vision is connected to success in both spheres.
Earlier, India was not looking to fill any kind of vacuum left by withdrawing American presence; it was willing to provide only “logistics” in areas such as counter-terrorism, intelligence building, protection of sea-lanes and capacity building. However, now New Delhi needs to take a fresh strategic look at the region, discarding many of its outdated political assumptions and initiate a sustained political engagement with all the major players (Iran, Saudis, Israel and Turkey).

Historically, Central Asia has close links with India. This region has become important not only as a vital supplier of natural resources and energy, but also on account of its geographical location at the crossroads between Europe and Asia. Due to proximity to the “superpowers” of China and Russia, Central Asia and Mongolia have experienced rapid industrialization and high growth since the year 2000. Mongolia remains completely surrounded by its two huge neighbors, China and Russia. Correspondingly, both countries dominate in foreign trade relations. China remains the recipient of around 90% of all Mongolian exports. China and Russia combined provide two thirds of all imports.
In multi-polar world, India needs to have a specific Central Command which would be responsible for operations in countries that fall in the “central Asia & Middle-East” area of the globe: Afghanistan, Bahrain, Egypt, Iran, Iraq, Jordan, Kazakhstan, Kuwait, Kyrgyzstan, Lebanon, Oman, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Syria, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, United Arab Emirates, Uzbekistan, Mongolia and Yemen. It utilizes national and international partnerships to build cooperation among nations, respond to crisis, deter and defeat threats and support development that ultimately increases stability in the region.

7.4       Africa

A subtle but sure competition is emerging between New Delhi and Beijing in courting Africa with each of these two rising countries in Asia offering wider choices for the African nations. “Beijing Consensus” of multilateralism, “non-intervention”, “no regime change”, “win-win” was counter posed in the last decade against the dominant Washington Consensus. India, with its democratic, anti-colonial and pro-G-77 credentials, offered a middle path approach of "Mumbai Consensus". South Africa, Kenya, Uganda & Ivory Coast remain important nations for India. More than half of investment in Africa comes from Europe, the United States and South Africa. From Asia, Singapore and India dominate investments in Africa.  Overall, In­dian investment in Africa is believed to be around $33 billion. India has been work­ing hard to nurture its relations with major oil-producing African countries, including Nigeria, Ghana, Equatorial Guinea, Côte d’Ivoire and Sudan. India is exploring uranium mining opportunities in Niger and Namibia. Furthermore, India is the world’s leading processor of diamonds, accounting for 85 percent in terms of volume on the total world market.

It is the West African Gulf of Guinea (encompassing the rich on and offshore fields stretching from Nigeria to Angola) which can be attractive alternative to the increasingly volatile and unpredictable oil-states of the Persian Gulf for India's entrench energy needs. Nigeria and Angola alone account for nearly four million barrels per day (almost half of Africa’s output). The strategic interests of India certainly include not only access to cheap and reliable low-sulphur oil imports, but also keeping at bay the Chinese (for example in Sudan) and South Koreans (for example in Nigeria), aggressive new players in the African oil business and Islamic terror.

India's African Command would involve military relations with African nations, the African Union and African regional security organizations. It would protect and defend the interests of India & its Diaspora by strengthening the defense capabilities of African nations and, in cooperation with African governments, conducts military missions that increase security while deterring and defeating a variety of transnational threats.

7.5       Central & South America

Rising power China has been active in this part of the world. Old dubbed “Mad Maria”, built in 1912 for booming rubber exports, the 367km (228-mile) line from Porto Velho in the heart of the Brazilian Amazon to the Bolivian border was rendered obsolete by new Asian plantations. A century later a plan for a much longer railway across the Amazon, from Brazil’s Atlantic coast to Peru, is among a sheaf of infrastructure projects that China is offering to finance in Latin America. Chinese companies would aim to invest $250 billion in Latin America over the next ten years, compared with a previous total stock of $99 billion. While early Chinese investment was almost wholly in oil, gas and mining, it is broadening out to involve more companies and industries, including food and agriculture, manufacturing and, above all, infrastructure. There is strategic value for China in establishing its own military presence in Central America, above and beyond the economic considerations. One such example, the $50 billion trans-oceanic shipping canal through Nicaragua, initial work for which began in December 2014, is now under construction. When completed, it is expected to bring major change to Central America and the surrounding region.

In case of India, Venezuela has become an important source of oil imports over the past decade. After the U.S. and China, India increased its global share to become the world’s third-largest oil importer. Indian companies like state-owned ONGC Videsh, Indian Oil Corporation and Oil India have invested in Venezuela’s Carabobo and San Cristobal oil fields, where oil is already being produced and exported to India and other markets. Reliance Industries has also signed a 15-year contract with PDVSA, Venezuelan’s State Oil Company, to import 400,000 barrels of oil per day. Also, Brazil, Argentina, Mexico and Chile remain crucial in India's strategy in Latin America.

For its strategic energy resource view and global reach, India needs a South / Central American (SOUCENAM) Command which would oversee an area of responsibility encompassing major partner nations in Latin America south of Mexico, Central and South America, and the Caribbean Sea. It would work to increase the security of India & Its Diaspora (mostly in Surinam & Caribbean) by engaging its partners to enhance the peacekeeping abilities of the region, to deter illegal activities associated with illicit trafficking and to conduct multinational military exercises designed to strengthen partnerships while developing collective capabilities.

7.6                   Arctic Region, Western Europe & North America

The strategic landscape of Europe’s neighborhood seems to be radically different today from the situation only a year ago. Just several hundred kilometers to the east of the EU’s and NATO’s borders Russia has launched a hybrid campaign against its neighbor. In the south, from the Middle East to North Africa (MENA), the accelerated rise of militant extremist groups is destabilizing the region with detrimental consequences for the security of the whole Euro-Atlantic area. We have even seen an unprecedented transformation of a terrorist movement into a quasi-state, threatening to bring jihad to Europe. The killings in Paris fulfilled this worst-case scenario. Europe’s failure to develop a shared strategic culture has not just undermined its ambition to be a more credible and effective actor, and therefore one that carries greater political weight, on the international scene – it has also hamstrung its efforts to maintain its defense capabilities in the wake of the financial crisis gripping the continent.

Big Power’s Challenge to Arctic Stability - As Russia builds up the Arctic, the United States has struggled to maintain a presence in the region. Although the U.S. assumed chairmanship of the Arctic Council in April 2015, it is falling behind both Russia and its own assessed need for assets to provide a presence in the Arctic region. The U.S. should use its role in the Arctic Council to build relationships with other Arctic nations, including Russia, while also making investments in naval assets to demonstrate that its interest in and commitment to the region are serious. By 2030, the Northern Sea Route will be passable to shipping for nine months a year. The route could cut down travel time between Europe and East Asia by as much as 60% compared to current routes through the Panama or Suez Canals. The US estimates that about 15% of the world's remaining oil, up to 30% of its natural gas deposits, and about 20% of its liquefied natural gas are stored in the Arctic seabed. In total, Moscow's plans involve the opening of ten Arctic search-and-rescue stations, 16 deep-water ports, 13 airfields, and 10 air-defense radar stations across its Arctic periphery. Russia, Denmark, Norway, Canada, and the US all have partial claims to the Arctic Circle. India as an 'Observer' in Arctic Council has a major role to play in future energy exploration and strategic aspects.

Here, India needs to have strategy to help its European friends in counterterrorism and mitigate threat perception from MENA. Also, India has to become aggressive in reducing or balancing Chinese/Russian Influence too (especially in Levant, Arctic region). Apart from maintaining good rapport with 'Big Three (Germany, UK & France) and USA/Canada, India needs to develop strategic relationship with Spain (for Latin America heritage), Portugal (for Brazil linkages) and Nordic Countries (for technologies & Arctic foothold). Here, India's proximity with Russia can used to provide security & counter-China leverage to European Union countries.

India's North American & European Command would work with USA, European and other partner nations to address the security and defense needs of nations in Europe and parts of North America & Arctic. It would coordinate with these nations to find cooperative solutions in peace and wartime alike, to plan training missions, provide humanitarian assistance and to develop strategies for promoting peace and stability in the region.

8.         Strategic Institutions -Think Tanks, NDMA, R & D

India has to invest substantial percentage of its GDP into 'Defense related institutions' from its current $50 billion or 2.4per cent of GDP. Here, private sector involvement would boost the progress in exploring newer areas in joint development of crucial technologies. However, government sponsored elite institution Defense Research & Development Organization (DRDO) has to play a major role. DRDO dedicatedly works towards enhancing self-reliance in Defense Systems and undertakes design & development leading to production of world class weapon systems and equipment in accordance with the expressed needs and the qualitative requirements laid down by the three defense services.

In the areas of strategic thinking, apart from existing IDSA (The Institute for Defense Studies and Analyses), CAPS (Centre for Air Power Studies), JNU (Jawaharlal Nehru University), ORF (Observer Research Foundation) many new Think Tanks from non-government sector (funded by private sector or high net-worth Individuals) has to grow. One such example is 'Gateway House' in Mumbai. It would provide credibility to the research & thinking done in security and strategic scene. India is also vulnerable to Chemical, Biological, Radiological and Nuclear (CBRN) emergencies and other man-made disasters. National Disaster Management Authority (NDMA) with its National Disaster Response Force (NDRF) for the purpose of specialized response to natural and man-made disasters requires extra emphasis.

In order to mitigate such unforeseen scenario, India has to enhance its supercomputers capability in civilian applications (such as weather forecasting) as well as military and intelligence applications. More research has to be done by intelligence agencies for cryptography and cryptanalysis (i.e. code breaking and code protection of encrypted electronic communications) as well as by the military for designing and modeling complete submarine hulls, developing non-acoustic anti-submarine warfare sensors, simulating nuclear weapons tests, chemical and biological weapons production, and designing improved nuclear weapons and ballistic missiles.

China’s military modernization has become a concern for India & western powers, and in particular the idea that China wanted to implement Network Centric Warfare, which was essentially how to use information technology to improve situational awareness and cue targeting systems, and in the end result in much more accurate targeting and destruction. The concern remains (through the acquisition of dual-use technologies) related to space, high-computing, and others, which would place China in a much better position to facilitate its transition to information-centered warfare. India has to adapt to sensitive technology transfers or development of signal and image recognition software, textiles for law-enforcement agencies uniforms, and night-vision equipment.

Recent presence of global Think Tanks (like Brookings, Carnegie, Aspen) in India has rightly projected the true importance of India as a major player in the world.

In this context, India urgently requires to enhance its national 'Special Strategic Command (SSC)' responsible for planning and conducting special operations. It would offer direct action in the form of short duration strikes and small-scale offensives, special reconnaissance, unconventional warfare, foreign internal defense, civil affairs operations, counterterrorism, psychological operations, information operations, counter-proliferation of weapons of mass destruction, security force assistance and counterinsurgency operations.

9.         Threat Perception

Asia, stretching from the east of Suez to the Pacific Ocean, is the locale of six states with nuclear weapon (China, DPRK, India, Israel, Pakistan, and Russia). Asia is also the venue of the fastest qualitative and quantitative proliferation of nuclear weapons. These developments have a direct impact on not only strategic stability in the region but also on strategic stability at the global level. How exactly will the proliferation challenges in Asia threaten regional and global strategic stability?  Will India be a "balancing power" or a "leading player"? Will India step in to play a peacemaker role in global hotspots as many countries keep demanding?

India has never known (so called Indian) Napoleons and Alexanders, though it has been the object of their desire. The reason is that the famous diversity of the Indian people has ensured that anyone who established his empire in this country had to constantly fight to preserve his gains, rather than export military power. The British, of course, were an exception, but don’t forget when they left, the country was divided into two. India must follow a policy of trying to co-opt Pakistan into its sub continental strategy and focus on the real adversary-China & Terrorism.

The People's Liberation Army Navy (PLAN) remains the naval warfare branch of the People's Liberation Army, the national armed forces of the People's Republic of China. PLAN signifies the credible role of submarines in the assertive maritime strategy of China which tactfully plays a role of gathering critical intelligence, and detecting movement of Indian vessels in the Indian Ocean Region (IOR) affecting Indian interdiction capabilities in the IOR. Further, it may evade comprehensive surveillance measures by India, facilitating hostile attacks on Indian shores. This also projects the grown Chinese confidence to assertively maneuver and maintain its standing presence in the Indian Ocean Region which has witnessed the unchallenged dominance of Indian Navy.

Recently, non-State actors have grown powerful and have strong international linkages and thus are challenging the nation-state stability in the region.

10.       Intelligence Gathering

The act of collecting intelligence about individuals, groups, or states of interest has come under increasing scrutiny. Similar to U.S. agencies such as RAND or Jane or Stratfor, intelligence collection, dissemination, analyzing and predicting / forecasting future trends has become necessity for resurgent global India. It has to be examined how India successfully collect intelligence, (similar to the U.S. intelligence community such as FBI, CIA, and NSA) ; how India can improve its intelligence-gathering capabilities, and how Indian military can make better use of its limited land, sea, and air-based intelligence collection assets in the rapidly changing battlefields of the future.

Here, India needs to enhance its expertise in Command, Control, Communications, Computing, Combat and Intelligence, Surveillance and Reconnaissance (C5ISR) systems, satellite communications, electronic warfare, unmanned systems, hypersonic systems, directed and high power energy systems, electromagnetic railgun, missile defense, cyber warfare, cyber security, information assurance, and critical infrastructure security. India needs this up-gradation in intelligence gathering capability.

11.       Cyber-risk, Weapons of Mass Destruction (WMD), Asymmetric Threat

Today, cyber security is widely viewed as a matter of pressing national importance. The nation’s critical infrastructure, including the electric power grid, air traffic control system, financial systems, and communication networks, depend extensively on information technology for its operation. Concerns about the vulnerability of the information technology on which the nation relies have deepened in the security-conscious environment and in light of increased cyber espionage directed at private companies and government agencies. National policy makers have become increasingly concerned that adversaries backed by considerable resources will attempt to exploit the cyber vulnerabilities in the critical infrastructure, thereby inflicting substantial harm on the nation.

In India, Department of Electronics and Information Technology (DeitY) has formulated 'National Cyber Security Policy-2013'.  Also, government bodies like National Informatics Centre (NIC), Indian Computer Emergency Response Team (Cert-In), and National Information Security Assurance Programme (NISAP) have major role to play in safeguarding India's digital eco-space. Also, Industry bodies have contributed towards crucial data security arena (Data Security Council of India DSCI).

The National Strategy for Countering Biological Threats (proposed) hopes to frame India's preparedness and response capacity against biological events, either naturally occurring or manmade. Biological pathogens could be prepared and deployed so that resulting infections have barely any semblance to the natural forms of the diseases. Overwhelming doses at the point of attack, and even at long distances downwind, as in the case of an aerosol delivery, could be thousands of times the “lethal dose”. In such cases, the resulting disease could be so severe that even medical countermeasures such as vaccines, antibiotics and antiviral could be rendered ineffective. Biological warfare can no longer be considered the purview of only state actors. And this democratization of biotechnology means that the world is literally one rogue microbiologist away from a potentially devastating biological attack. Imagine a group like the Islamic State group with the capability and intentions of employing large-scale biological weapons. India's nascent entity NDMA, NDRF and national / state level civil defense has to be upgraded substantially to mitigate natural or man-made calamity situation.

Recently, Network Centric Warfare (NCW) has become necessary as an information superiority-enabled concept of operations that generates increased combat power by networking sensors, decision makers, and shooters to achieve shared awareness, increased speed of command, higher tempo of operations, greater lethality, increased survivability, and a degree of self synchronization. In essence, NCW translates information superiority into combat power by effectively linking knowledgeable entities in the battle space.  Bharat Electronics Ltd (BEL), a government of India unit, has the complete solution for the implementation of the backbone network i.e. Tactical Communication System (TCS).
India's Strategic Command (SC) along with SSC would be responsible for command of India's nuclear capabilities, space operations, global surveillance and reconnaissance, intelligence, communications, computers, global missile defense and combating weapons of mass destruction.

12.       Command, Control, Communication  

India has to enhance its C4ISR capability of Command, Control, Communications, Computers, Intelligence, Surveillance and Reconnaissance for projecting its reach globally. Proposed infrastructure enabling Global Command and Control System  (GCCS) would support six mission areas (operations, mobilization, deployment, employment, sustainment, and intelligence) through eight functional areas: threat identification and assessment, strategy planning aids, course of action development, execution planning, implementation, monitoring, risk analysis, and a common tactical picture.

As a major player with global reach, India needs capability in its Expeditionary Aerospace Operations, moving information instead of people. Such operation would change the dynamics of the force deployment process by enabling split base operations. The Air Force Space Command’s Attack and Launch Early Reporting to Theater (ALERT) capability provides an existence proof of the operational benefit of a sensor network in generating increased battle-space awareness against ballistic missiles. The application of NCW to a military situation or problem requires starting with a clean sheet of paper and designing a mission capability package from scratch, finding the most appropriate combination of a concept of operations, an approach to command and control, an organizational structure, a set of information flows, all to be matched with appropriate sensor and engagement capabilities.

For dealing with such a complex situation in its neighborhood and to maintain credible consistent influence in the Indian Ocean Region and beyond, India has already started creating partnerships to plug these critical gaps. In doing so, military exercises and mature interoperability would hold the key in establishing military-to-military linkages amongst the strong militaries of the region which have a global reach. It can also be leveraged for joint surveillance by sharing information as also for strengthening cooperation in the field of logistics to achieve more comprehensive coverage.

The enlargement of India’s thermonuclear program would position the country alongside the United Kingdom, the United States, Russia, Israel, France, and China, which already have significant stockpiles of such weapons. India intends to build thermonuclear weapons as part of its strategic deterrent against China. India presently has just one indigenous nuclear vessel, the INS Arihant, powered by an 80-megawatt uranium reactor developed by Bhabha Atomic Research Center (BARC) a major Indian research establishment. A second, INS Aridhaman, is under construction, with at least two more slated to be built. Each would be loaded with up to 12 nuclear-tipped missiles. India needs to constantly rethink what deterrence means, as it is not a static notion, and everyone understands that. In Indo-Pacific region, U.S. wants something intangible; to create a new strategic partner (India) capable of facing down China, and so India has taken advantage of the situation to overhaul its military nuclear capability.

13.       Operational Reach

Major relocation and uplifting of tactical assets or civilians operation in a crisis-ridden terrain with minimum delay would fall on India's 'Transportation Command (TC)'. It provides the three arms of security forces with an aggregate of transportation capabilities and assets. Along with commercial partnerships, it enables a diverse array of joint mobility missions in crisis management, involving early entry into a potentially hostile territory (including the initial enforcement of no-fly zones, embargoes and sanctions), the protection of shared national interests abroad, extraction operations, non-combatant evacuation operations, the temporary strengthening of a peacekeeping operation, support to emergency humanitarian assistance. India has successfully carried out such operation in Kuwait /Syria conflict and Yemen civil war.

For achieving 'Blue Ocean Fleet', India needs to have 'Carrier Strike Groups (CSGs)' and 'Amphibious Ready Groups (ARGs)' located at strategic locations world-wide to project India's presence in case of any unforeseen necessity. CSGs and ARGs will become the keys to India's dominance over the world's oceans. A CSG may be centered on an aircraft carrier, which projects naval and air power. The CSG includes significant offensive strike capability. An ARG may be centered on three amphibious warfare ships, with a Marine Expeditionary Unit (MEU) embarked. Elite MEU built around a heavily reinforced and mobile battalion of Marines can carry out designated mission to a final closure.

Whenever any crisis or conflict arises affecting India's national interest worldwide, the Combined Joint Expeditionary Force would be envisaged as a deployable, combined military force for use in a wide range of crisis scenarios including high intensity combat operations. As a joint force, it involves all three armed services: a land component composed of formations at national brigade level, maritime and air components with their associated headquarters, together with logistics and support functions. It would be able to conduct offensive and defensive operations on land, in the air, and at sea. It is designed to be rapidly deployable and, once ready in theatre, to be sustainable for up to three months of operations as a stand-alone force; as well as having the ability to include other nations as coalition partners.

14.       Conclusion

India’s path to become a great power may be overly militaristic, the assertion of an Indian Monroe doctrine, the resumption of thermonuclear testing, establishing military bases abroad, arming Vietnam, building a military-industrial complex, enhancing cooperation with the US and its allies and so on. India has the resources to be an outward thrusting power. Whether it is Central or South-east Asia or Africa, India’s investment and trade volume has to increase many-fold to achieve respectable presence in the world. Military power must always be a function of national economic power, not the other way around. Before India becomes a great power, it must be a nation of Indians not getting bogged-down with the politics of the religion, ethnicity, caste and linguistic identities. Without an emphatic national identity, asserting a greater Indian vision and strategy will not be easy. Furthermore, a nation that inclines to Monrovian thinking is a nation with considerable potential for sea power, since a hegemon puts its hands-off policy into effect chiefly on the high seas. And finally, a local hegemon with an anti-imperial and nonaligned past will likely find the Monroe Doctrine congenial.
  
References

1. http://csis.org/files/media/csis/pubs/090201_bsa_chandran.pdf
2. http://www.mofa.go.jp/s_sa/sw/in/page3e_000432.html (Indo-JP Relations)
3. India as an Emerging Power By Sumit Ganguly
4. India-US Joint Strategic Vision: A New Regional Role for Delhi? Darshana M. Baruah)
5. India's National Security: Military Challenges and Responses, Volume 1 by Kuldip Singh Bajwa
6. http://www.brookings.in/wp-content/uploads/wp-post-to-pdf-cache/1/wps-sidhu-on-contemporary-geopolitics.pdf
7. http://www.chairestrategique.fr/IMG/pdf/vision_strategique_de_linde_pour_le_xxie_siecle.pdf
8.http://www.indiastrategic.in/topstories3947_Modis_leap_of_vision_Is_India_ready_for_a_larger_role.htm
9. http://indiatoday.intoday.in/story/pm-modi-global-push-aggressive-foreign-policy-will-it-work/1/487299.html
10. http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/2015/12/us-comprehensive-strategy-toward-russia
11. https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/indias-new-maritime-strategy-brand-building-era-discord-singh
13.https://www.commerzbank.com/media/institutions/fi_topic/insights/Insights_Central_Asia_final.pdf

14. India-Venezuela Relations, Ministry of External Affairs, Government of India. ( http://mea.gov.in/Portal/ForeignRelation/Venezuela_2015_07_09.pdf)

No comments:

Post a Comment